The honeymoon interval between Tamil Nadu chief minister C Joseph Vijay’s Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) and its coalition associate, the Congress, seems to be over. Barely months after the 2 events got here collectively to kind the federal government, they’re already sparring over a query that’s ostensibly concerning the 2029 Lok Sabha election: Who must be the opposition’s prime ministerial face – Rahul Gandhi or Vijay?What started as statements and counter-statements between the 2 occasion leaders has rapidly acquired a sharper political edge.TVK PWD minister Aadhav Arjuna pitched Vijay as a possible nationwide chief, arguing that the nation’s highest political workplace ought to go to a pacesetter from Tamil Nadu. Then again, state minister S Rajesh Kumar stated Congress ministers within the Tamil Nadu cupboard would resign if TVK didn’t assist Rahul Gandhi because the PM candidate in 2029.The confrontation spilled into the meeting as nicely. Congress Legislature Get together chief and MLA Tharahai Cuthbert was shifted on August 31 from the part allotted to TVK legislators to the entrance row of the opposition benches.However beneath the instant battle over Rahul versus Vijay lies a a lot greater query: Does Vijay intend to stay a strong Tamil Nadu chief, or does he see the state’s 2026 mandate because the launchpad for a nationwide political challenge?And if the latter is the plan, can he succeed the place Arvind Kejriwal couldn’t?
Vijay’s extraordinary first step
The size of Vijay’s rise explains why the 2029 debate has surfaced so early.The April 2026 Tamil Nadu meeting election ended almost six a long time of dominance by the DMK and AIADMK. TVK, solely two years previous, emerged as the biggest occasion with 108 seats within the 234-member meeting. The DMK gained 59 and AIADMK 47, whereas Congress secured 5 seats, with the remaining seats going to smaller allies.TVK was due to this fact not merely a brand new occasion that carried out higher than anticipated. It emerged because the central political power in an election that disrupted the state’s conventional two-party equilibrium.There was, nonetheless, one drawback: 108 seats had been nonetheless in need of the 118 required for a easy majority.That made Congress indispensable.Vijay ultimately shaped the federal government with the assist of MLAs from Congress [5], VCK [2] and IUML [2], together with outdoors assist from the Left events [4]. The MDMK, which has two MLAs, later prolonged its assist.Congress moved away from its long-standing affiliation with the DMK and backed a TVK-led authorities together with smaller allies, taking the coalition’s power to 121. Vijay was sworn in as CM on Might 10.Congress had submitted its letter of assist after the election, making it clear that its assist could be conditional on TVK preserving “communal forces” out of the alliance.
Vijay emerged because the disrupter-in-chief in Tamil Nadu elections.
The 234-member meeting at the moment has seven vacancies following the resignation of six AIADMK MLAs and Vijay vacating his second seat, Trichy East. The efficient power of the Home is due to this fact 227, bringing the bulk mark all the way down to 114.The political equation is uncommon. Congress is the junior associate, with solely 5 seats, however its assist helped Vijay cross the bulk mark. On the similar time, TVK’s 108 seats give Vijay overwhelming dominance inside the coalition.That inversion could also be on the coronary heart of the current pressure.Congress had been with the DMK within the pre-poll alliance and had by no means secured a spot in MK Stalin’s cupboard. After the outcomes, nonetheless, it rapidly moved to TVK’s facet and helped Vijay kind the federal government.The alliance due to this fact comprises a built-in contradiction: the occasion that wants Vijay’s authorities to outlive doesn’t need Vijay to emerge because the chief of the nationwide opposition.
Congress chief on TVK’s ‘Vijay-for-PM’ pitch.
The ‘agnipath’ of Vijay’s path
Vijay’s path to Delhi runs into an issue that no quantity of success in Tamil Nadu can completely remedy: numbers.Tamil Nadu sends 39 MPs to the Lok Sabha. Even a TVK sweep in 2029 would depart Vijay nowhere near the 272 seats wanted for a majority within the 543-member Home.Historical past, nonetheless, gives slightly hope.Previously, India has had PMs whose events didn’t come near a Lok Sabha majority. HD Deve Gowda turned PM in 1996 after the Janata Dal gained simply 46 seats, rising because the consensus alternative of the United Entrance with Congress assist. IK Gujral adopted a yr later below a lot the identical association, with the Janata Dal holding solely round 45 seats. Chandra Shekhar turned prime minister in 1990 after breaking away from the Janata Dal with simply 64 MPs, counting on outdoors assist from Congress.This will give Vijay some hope.However additionally it is the place the historic comparability begins to fray. The coalition politics that made these leaders PMs belonged to a special nationwide panorama the place coalition governments had been a norm. The BJP, nonetheless, has modified that equation, constructing the NDA right into a sturdy nationwide coalition relatively than the free, post-election preparations that outlined a lot of the Nineties.The opposition, in the meantime, has come collectively within the type of the INDIA bloc which Vijay’s TVK just isn’t a part of but.And but, paradoxically, being outdoors the INDIA bloc might give Vijay a bonus over Rahul Gandhi.Rahul comes with the load of the Congress’s historical past: its nationwide footprint, its alliances and rivalries, the Nehru-Gandhi legacy and the political resistance that the occasion can provoke amongst regional leaders. Vijay comes with a lot much less baggage. He would enter a coalition dialog not because the chief of a decades-old nationwide occasion, however as a brand new political power with a mass following constructed earlier than he entered politics.
Rahul Gandhi’s political journey.
That distinction might matter if the subsequent Lok Sabha produces one other fractured mandate. However that could be a massive if, and one that appears unlikely within the current circumstances.Congress MP Karti Chidambaram has already put the arithmetic bluntly: “Each occasion has desires, ambitions, and needs … however we all know what the political actuality is. There are 543 constituencies.”Thus, for Vijay, even when his occasion manages to comb all 39 Tamil Nadu seats, the true check could be to find sufficient allies to make Delhi doable.
Can Tamil Nadu be Vijay’s launchpad?
There may be, nonetheless, one route Vijay might try that will give his nationwide challenge a definite political id.He might construct round Tamil Nadu’s distinctive relationship with the Centre and a broader southern assertion in nationwide politics — the argument that Delhi wants a stronger voice from a area that has traditionally resisted political and cultural centralisation.That might give TVK’s nationwide challenge a political argument past Vijay’s superstar and the anti-incumbency in opposition to established events.Nevertheless it comes with its personal drawback.
BJP has used the chance to query TVK-Congress alliance.
A political id rooted in Tamil satisfaction and southern assertion may fit strongly in Tamil Nadu, however it doesn’t robotically translate into votes in Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra, West Bengal or different states.Vijay would due to this fact must steadiness two identities: the Tamil chief whose legitimacy comes from Tamil Nadu and the nationwide chief who should persuade voters elsewhere that his politics just isn’t confined to the state.
Why Congress can’t merely step apart
For Congress, the dispute just isn’t merely about Rahul Gandhi’s private ambitions or the way forward for the Gandhi household. It’s about whether or not the occasion can retain its place because the principal nationwide pole of the opposition after years of organisational and electoral decline.Rahul has spent years positioning himself because the principal challenger to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP. Congress’s improved efficiency within the 2024 Lok Sabha election and Rahul’s emergence as chief of opposition strengthened that declare.The following meeting elections, nonetheless, have weakened the occasion’s place in opposition to the BJP.A latest survey inserting Rahul because the second-most most well-liked PM alternative and Vijay subsequent is however important. Vijay’s place is exceptional for a pacesetter whose occasion has contested just one meeting election, regardless that such surveys are hardly an alternative to precise elections.For Congress, conceding the nationwide management query to Vijay now would threat permitting one other regional chief to occupy the political area the occasion is attempting to reclaim, particularly after the weakened positioning of Mamata Banerjee, MK Stalin and Kejriwal.
The Kejriwal check
Kejriwal additionally started with a rare political breakthrough in a single territory earlier than making an attempt to show his occasion right into a nationwide different.When he launched the Aam Aadmi Get together (AAP) in November 2012, his political challenge was constructed round difficult established events, significantly Congress, which had ruled Delhi for 15 years below Sheila Dikshit.AAP’s breakthrough got here nearly instantly. Kejriwal turned CM in December 2013, resigned after 49 days and returned in February 2015 with one of the emphatic mandates in Indian electoral politics: AAP gained 67 of Delhi’s 70 meeting seats, decreasing Congress to zero.However Kejriwal didn’t intend to cease at Delhi.The 2014 Lok Sabha election was his first main try and construct a nationwide footprint. AAP contested 432 seats and gained 4, all in Punjab. Kejriwal himself challenged Narendra Modi in Varanasi, whereas Kumar Vishwas contested Amethi in opposition to Rahul Gandhi. Neither problem produced the nationwide breakthrough AAP was in search of.The occasion then entered the Punjab and Goa meeting elections in 2017. Punjab turned a second political laboratory, with AAP profitable 20 of 117 seats and rising because the principal opposition power behind Congress. Goa, nonetheless, uncovered the bounds of the enlargement technique, with AAP failing to win a single meeting seat.Punjab ultimately offered the large breakthrough. Within the 2022 election, AAP gained 92 of 117 seats and shaped a authorities below Bhagwant Mann.Kejriwal had due to this fact achieved one thing genuinely troublesome: he had constructed governments in two states and turned AAP right into a recognisable political power past Delhi.But the nationwide leap remained elusive.AAP’s electoral power outdoors its core states by no means matched the dimensions of its Delhi and Punjab victories. In Gujarat, the place it tried to ascertain itself as a 3rd power, the occasion gained 5 meeting seats in 2022, whereas Goa remained marginal. Its Lok Sabha presence additionally remained modest.
Vijay’s one-point lead on Kejriwal
The Tamil Nadu CM has one benefit over Kejriwal although that their beginning factors are totally different.Kejriwal needed to construct a mass political id nearly from scratch. Vijay, nonetheless, spent a long time constructing one via cinema earlier than coming into politics. He then transformed that reputation into 108 meeting seats in his very first election, which was dubbed as a rare political conversion.However it could actually additionally turn out to be a weak point.The query is now not whether or not hundreds of thousands of individuals know Vijay. They do.The query is whether or not voters who know him as an actor and Tamil Nadu CM will vote for TVK in states the place the occasion has no political historical past, native management or cadre community.To go nationwide, Vijay would want candidates, native leaders, a cadre community and alliances. Most significantly, he would want a political proposition that resonates with voters who have no idea him primarily as a Tamil movie star.That is the place Kejriwal’s expertise issues most.AAP’s success in Delhi couldn’t merely be reproduced throughout the nation. Punjab supplied a beneficial political opening, however Goa and Gujarat demonstrated that nationwide visibility and electoral organisation are very various things.Vijay’s process might be even tougher as a result of lots of the states he would want to enter have already got highly effective regional leaders with their very own political ambitions.For now, the 2029 PM debate might due to this fact be untimely, however the political battle it has uncovered just isn’t. Vijay may have Congress to consolidate the facility he has gained in Tamil Nadu at the same time as he seeks to problem Congress’s declare to nationwide opposition management.
Share your ideas within the feedback
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
That’s the paradox on the coronary heart of his political challenge.If Vijay can use the Congress alliance to construct a sturdy organisation with out changing into politically depending on it, he might have discovered a route Kejriwal couldn’t. But when TVK’s nationwide ambitions stay forward of its organisational attain, the 2029 debate might find yourself trying much less like the start of a nationwide problem and extra like the primary signal of a regional occasion reaching past its electoral weight.