Bollywood actor Swara Bhasker lately grabbed headlines after her remarks on Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Padmaavat Jauhar scene. The actor referred to as the scene “problematic”, inviting backlash on social media. Now, actor Ranvir Shorey has additionally criticised Swara’s remarks, calling her “totally shameless”.
Ranvir Shorey slams Swara Bhasker’s remarks on Padmaavat’s Jauhar scene
Ranvir took to X to criticise Swara for her remarks and questioned the connection she drew between Jauhar and rape survivors. He wrote, “I nonetheless don’t get it! Evaluating Jauhar (suicide by hearth in defiance of inevitable and countless rape, violence and even necrophilia!) to rape survivors? The place’s the connection? They’re two utterly totally different units! The one intention could be to malign one group of individuals whereas attempting to whitewash the opposite! Totally shameless!”
What did Swara Bhasker say?
Swara had written an open letter to Sanjay Leela Bhansali after the discharge of Padmaavat. When requested in regards to the letter, Swara made a controversial comment in regards to the Jauhar scene throughout a Girl, Life, Freedom discuss on the India Worldwide Centre in Delhi. She mentioned, “I used to be watching it, and I assumed that if God forbid, I used to be a rape survivor, what is that this movie telling me? I might really feel like a coward that I didn’t commit suicide to avoid wasting my honour. Is that what you wish to inform in a society like ours the place I really feel like, anyway, there’s a rape epidemic? Is that this what we wish to inform our survivors that they don’t need to stay, that should you really would have been an honourable and courageous girl, you’ll have killed your self. Are we saying that rape is the tip of a girl’s life? This scene was so problematic.”
She added that one specific scene made her extraordinarily offended. She recalled a close-up shot of a pregnant girl’s stomach as she carried out Jauhar, which left her shouting, “Chii” in disgust. She questioned the concept the unborn fetus, which might probably be a lady, didn’t need to be born as a result of she may be raped by a Muslim ruler. Swara mentioned she was deeply upset by the scene and waited for 5 days to see if she nonetheless felt the identical manner earlier than writing the letter.
The actor confronted backlash for her remarks, with many criticising her interpretation of the Jauhar sequence and arguing that the historic follow shouldn’t be described as cowardice. Later, Swara took to Instagram and shared a video message explaining that she didn’t name Rani Padmavati “coward”. She additional questioned whether or not movies like Padmaavat needs to be made in the event that they “ship the message {that a} girl’s purity is extra invaluable than her life?”
She added, “Ought to we be telling a rape survivor that it could have been higher if she had died, and that surviving the assault was a nasty factor?”
After Swara’s remarks, Padmaavat author Prakash Kapadia got here out in help of the scene. He referred to as the Jauhar sequence the “actuality of these instances” and mentioned that whereas he had not been following Swara’s feedback, the controversy felt pointless to him.